INSIGHTS & IDEAS

4 Ways to Increase Teacher Buy-In Towards Inclusive Practices & UDL

teacher buy in on inclusive practices and udl
4 Ways to Increase Teacher Buy-In Towards Inclusive Practices & UDL
3:59

Creating more inclusive schools isn't simply about introducing new instructional strategies. It requires leaders to establish a shared vision, understand educators' perspectives, build collective confidence, and provide the ongoing support needed to turn that vision into classroom practice.

Educators bring different experiences, beliefs, strengths, and concerns to improvement efforts. Some may be excited to try new approaches but need practical resources. Others may have the necessary skills but question whether a change will benefit their students. Effective leadership requires recognizing these differences and responding with clarity, collaboration, and support.

Here are four ways leaders can build commitment to inclusive practices and Universal Design for Learning (UDL).

1. Establish a Clear Vision and Shared Purpose

Before asking educators to change their practices, make sure they understand what you're working toward, why it matters for students, and what it should look like in every classroom. Without a clear instructional vision that identifies specific expectations for teaching and learning, educators may be left wondering what they're actually supposed to do differently.

Consider what you want students to experience in every classroom. For example, inclusive instruction in your school might mean every lesson begins with an Inclusive Welcome that incorporates a total participation technique, teachers consistently communicate what students are learning and why, and students make daily choices about how they work toward firm learning goals through flexible pathways that maintain high expectations. Whatever your priorities, make those instructional practices explicit.

When expectations are clear, educators can reflect on how their current practices already align with the vision, identify areas for growth, and make meaningful shifts over time. Leaders can then align professional learning, coaching, collaboration, and feedback to those shared expectations.

A clear instructional vision isn't about requiring every teacher to teach the same way. It's about establishing consistent expectations for student experiences while honoring educator expertise and flexibility in how those expectations are met.

 

2. Understand Concerns and Support Mindset Shifts

Not every educator approaches change from the same starting point. Some may need more information, others may worry about managing new expectations, and some may hold beliefs about student ability, independence, or inclusion that influence their instructional decisions.

Rather than interpreting questions or hesitation as resistance, seek to understand what's behind them. Remember that some changes are technical, requiring educators to learn new strategies, while others are adaptive, requiring shifts in beliefs and established practices. Both deserve intentional leadership support.

One strategy is to use a simple three-step protocol when educators express concerns about inclusive practices:

  1. Understand the concern. Listen without immediately offering a solution. Ask questions such as, "What concerns you most about this approach?" or "What have you experienced when you've tried something similar?" Consider the educator's beliefs, experiences, confidence, and skills.
  2. Identify the leadership need. Determine what might help the educator move forward. Do they need greater clarity about expectations, opportunities to observe a colleague, instructional modeling, coaching, collaboration, resources, or more autonomy in how they implement the practice?
  3. Plan your leadership move. Acknowledge the concern while maintaining high expectations. For example, if a teacher says, "My students can't make responsible choices," you might respond, "Making informed choices is a skill students need to learn. What if we started with two structured options and explicitly taught students how to choose?" Identify one manageable next step and offer support.

Beyond individual conversations, create opportunities for educators to examine their beliefs through student work, classroom observations, collaborative inquiry, and student feedback. For example, invite teachers to observe a classroom where students successfully make choices about their learning, then reflect on the instructional routines and supports that made that independence possible.

The goal isn't to eliminate discomfort because, let's face it, sometimes change is uncomfortable! Instead, it's to create opportunities for reflection, maintain high expectations for every student, and help educators see what's possible.

To learn about one school's journey shifting mindsets, read  One school’s journey to inclusion through educator learning.

3. Build Confidence Through Small, Meaningful Changes

Before focusing on what needs to improve, recognize the effective practices already happening in classrooms. Help educators see how their existing strengths can serve as a foundation for more inclusive instruction.

One way to do this is through the UDL Focus Areas, which help educators reflect on their current practices and identify meaningful next steps. Rather than trying to improve everything at once, encourage teachers to select one focus area, identify their starting point, and build instructional routines that help them move toward the next level of implementation.

For example, a teacher focusing on student voice and reflection might begin by incorporating a brief daily check-in where students reflect on their learning and identify what they need next. As the routine becomes more established, students can take greater ownership of monitoring their progress and making informed decisions about their learning.  Encourage educators to use the student reflection questions within each Focus Area to gather feedback and monitor progress. Are students experiencing the intended changes? What is working, and what might need to be adjusted? These conversations help teachers see the impact of small instructional shifts and make informed decisions about what to try next.

Celebrate progress and create opportunities for educators to share what they're learning. When teachers recognize their growth, see the impact on students, and learn from one another, they build both individual and collective efficacy.

 

4. Provide Ongoing Support and Shared Resources

Professional learning alone rarely leads to sustained changes in classroom practice. Educators need time, resources, coaching, collaboration, and feedback to apply what they're learning. Leaders can make implementation more manageable by embedding support into existing structures rather than adding more to educators' workloads.

Consider these practical strategies:

  • Protect collaborative planning time. Repurpose a faculty meeting or PLC session so teachers can work together to revise an upcoming lesson using UDL, share ideas, and anticipate barriers to learning.
  • Create a shared library of resources. Develop a common folder with examples of inclusive instructional routines, flexible assessment options, scaffolds, and lesson plans. Invite educators to contribute strategies they've successfully implemented.
  • Make effective practices visible. Organize brief learning walks, peer observations, or classroom demonstrations focused on one instructional practice. Follow up with opportunities to reflect on what teachers noticed and how they might adapt the practice.
  • Create opportunities to share small wins. Dedicate five minutes of a faculty meeting or PLC to educators sharing a strategy they've tried, what they noticed about student learning, and what they plan to adjust.
  • Ask educators what support they need. Use brief surveys, check-ins, or collaborative conversations to identify barriers to implementation. Then respond by adjusting resources, schedules, professional learning, or coaching opportunities.

Use evidence of instructional practices, student experiences, and student outcomes to understand what's working and where additional support is needed. Remember that implementation is an ongoing process, and educators need opportunities to practice, reflect, receive feedback, and refine their approaches.

Sustainable change happens when educators are not simply expected to implement a vision but are supported and empowered to bring it to life.

Also, check out the podcast episode to learn more.