As a writer, sometimes I get an idea that inspires me, and I can't stop thinking about it. Eventually, that idea turns into a goal, like, "I should totally write a book about that!"
Publishing the book is the final outcome. It's like a summative assessment, where I get to see how well I've accomplished what I set out to do. And there is SO much flexibility in how I get there. I can write in the morning or late at night, outline chapters before I start or jump right into writing, and change my approach a hundred times along the way.
Here's the thing, though. When you work with a publisher, there are lots of deadlines before the book is actually published. I have to submit outlines, sample chapters, and eventually an entire manuscript. Those deadlines are a lot like formative assessments.
My work doesn't have to be perfect at those checkpoints. Sometimes, one could argue it's not even very good! But that's the point. Each deadline is an opportunity to share what I've accomplished, get feedback, reflect on what's working and what isn't, and recalibrate my approach as I work toward the final goal.
Imagine if my publisher never looked at anything I wrote until the book was finished. What if I spent months writing something that didn't align with our vision? Or what if I was struggling with a chapter but didn't realize there was a better way to approach it? Without those checkpoints, I could spend a whole lot of time heading in the wrong direction.
The same is true for our students.
Assessment is an essential part of teaching and learning, but its purpose is so much more than measuring what students know. When we use assessment effectively, it becomes a tool for learning, helping both educators and students make informed decisions about what comes next.
Research on formative assessment, including the foundational work of Black and Wiliam (1998), emphasizes that assessment has the greatest potential to improve learning when evidence is used to adjust teaching and learning. This is an important distinction. Simply collecting data, administering a quiz, or providing feedback does not necessarily make an assessment formative. What matters is what teachers and students do with the evidence.
Formative assessment is assessment for learning. It allows us, as educators, to learn what students already know, what they understand, and where they need additional support so we can adjust our instruction, differentiate instruction for individual students, and provide targeted feedback. At the same time, it provides opportunities for students to reflect on what they know, recognize their progress, identify what they still need to work on, and shift their learning strategies if necessary.
When teachers and students have clarity about the intended learning, they can use evidence to make more informed decisions about how to move forward.
Formative and Summative: It's About Purpose, Not Format
One important misconception is that formative assessments are informal, while summative assessments are formal and documented. As Lee Ann Jung emphasized recently at the EARCOS Conference in Bangkok in October 2026, both formative and summative assessments can be formal or informal. The distinction is not the assessment format but its purpose and how the evidence is used.
For example, a written quiz can be formative if the teacher uses the results to identify misconceptions, provide targeted instruction, or adjust upcoming lessons. Similarly, a student explaining a concept during a conversation might provide evidence of learning that contributes to a summative judgment.
Think of the summative assessment as the destination and formative assessments as checkpoints along the way. When we know where students are headed, we can intentionally design opportunities to determine whether they are making progress and what they need to continue moving forward.
And while publishing a book is, in fact, a formalized summative assessment of my work, summative assessments in the classroom don't have to be formal, lengthy, or even written. They simply need to provide evidence of whether students have met the intended learning outcomes. Just like formative assessments, summative assessments can take many forms. But determining which forms are appropriate requires us to start with the destination.
Start With the Destination
UDL is all about firm goals and flexible means, so when designing a unit of instruction, we need to be super clear about what students should know and be able to do by the end of the learning experience and how we will know whether they have met those outcomes. For example, imagine a high school biology unit focused on genetics. The intended unit outcome is:
Construct and use a model to explain how genetic information is passed from parents to offspring through meiosis and fertilization, and explain how recombination and mutations contribute to genetic variation using scientific evidence.
This is the destination. Students will need to develop knowledge about DNA, chromosomes, meiosis, fertilization, and genetic variation. They will also need opportunities to practice constructing models, analyzing evidence, and supporting scientific explanations.
If this were our course, we would not simply teach these concepts and wait until the end of the unit to find out whether students understand them. Instead, we would need to identify the learning objectives that build toward the summative assessment and intentionally plan checkpoints along the way.
Sample Learning Progression: Modes of Inheritance
The following example shows how the genetics unit goal can be broken into a sequence of learning objectives that build toward the summative assessment. Notice how the objectives address both the knowledge students need to develop and the skills they will use to demonstrate their learning. For example, because the summative assessment requires students to construct models, analyze evidence, and support explanations, these skills are intentionally developed and practiced throughout the unit. Each lesson, therefore, provides an oportunity for a teacher to design a formative assessment.
Describe the relationships among DNA, genes, and chromosomes and their roles in storing genetic information.
Explain how DNA replication produces copies of genetic information before cell division.
Explain how homologous chromosomes carry genes inherited from each parent, including different versions (alleles) of the same genes.
Develop and use a model to explain how meiosis reduces chromosome number to produce haploid gametes.
Use a model to explain how crossing over during meiosis produces new combinations of genetic information.
Use a model to explain how independent assortment contributes to genetic variation.
Develop and use a model to explain how meiosis and fertilization maintain chromosome number across generations.
Explain how mutations change DNA sequences and may affect traits.
Analyze scientific evidence to explain how recombination and mutations contribute to genetic variation among individuals.
Summative Assessment
Construct and use a model to explain how genetic information is passed from parents to offspring through meiosis and fertilization, and explain how recombination and mutations contribute to genetic variation using scientific evidence.
Formative Assessment Is for Learning, Not Grading
Let's go back to my book analogy for a minute. Imagine if every draft I submitted to my publisher received a grade, and all those grades were averaged together to determine the quality of my final book. That would be ridiculous! The whole point of submitting drafts is to get feedback, learn what I need to improve, and make revisions. Some of my early drafts are pretty rough, but they shouldn't count against me once I've done the work to improve them.
The same should be true for our students.
As Ken O'Connor argues in A Repair Kit for Grading, formative assessments should be used to provide feedback and guide learning, not to calculate students' final grades. That doesn't mean students shouldn't know how they're doing. Teachers can absolutely mark formative assessments, provide scores, or use rubrics to communicate progress toward learning goals. But those marks should be information students can use to improve, not points that penalize them for still learning.
I know some schools require teachers to post a certain number of grades each week, but that doesn't mean every grade needs to count toward a student's final achievement grade. If that's the expectation in your school, consider communicating to families that formative assessments will be marked and posted to show progress, but those marks will not be averaged into final achievement grades, which should reflect the most accurate and current evidence of what students know and can do. Another option is to allow students to revisit and revise formative assessments based on feedback, so their marks reflect their growing understanding rather than where they started. Of course, this depends on your school's grading policies, but the goal should always be to communicate learning, not penalize students for the process of learning.
Think about our genetics unit. After Lesson 4, a student might construct a model of meiosis that doesn't accurately represent how chromosome numbers are reduced. That's important information. The teacher now knows what needs to be addressed, and the student has an opportunity to revisit the model, get feedback, and improve their understanding.
But why would we average that early attempt into a final grade if, by the end of the unit, the student can accurately construct and use a model to explain the process? If our goal is to communicate what students know and can do at the end of a unit, their grades should reflect that learning, not every mistake they made along the way.
This doesn't mean formative assessments are optional or that students shouldn't be accountable for participating in the learning process. Students need to engage in practice, receive feedback, reflect, and make adjustments. But we want them to see formative assessment as an opportunity to grow, not an opportunity to lose points.
When students know that mistakes during practice won't permanently lower their grades, we create more opportunities for them to take risks, ask questions, use feedback, and develop the skills they need to develop agency and become more independent learners.
Arriving at the Destination: Summative Assessment
Eventually, my publisher and I reach the point when the book is ready to be published. After all the drafts, feedback, revisions, and probably a few moments when I questioned why I decided to write another book in the first place, we have a final product.
That's our summative assessment.
In the classroom, summative assessment provides evidence of the extent to which students have achieved the intended learning outcomes. And just like formative assessment, there can be lots of flexibility in how students demonstrate what they know and can do.
Let's return to our genetics unit. Remember, the intended outcome is for students to construct and use a model to explain how genetic information is passed from parents to offspring through meiosis and fertilization, and explain how recombination and mutations contribute to genetic variation using scientific evidence. For the summative assessment, students could construct a physical model, develop a digital model, or create a series of annotated diagrams. Heck, if someone wants to make another cake, I'm not going to stop them! But regardless of the format, every student needs to demonstrate the same intended knowledge and skills.
We also need to be thoughtful about what we're assessing. A beautifully decorated cake doesn't necessarily demonstrate a strong understanding of meiosis, just as a polished digital presentation doesn't automatically demonstrate scientific reasoning. The success criteria should focus on the accuracy of the model, the quality of the explanation, and the student's ability to use scientific evidence, not the artistic quality or the charisma displayed in their presentation of their model.
And what happens if a student consistently demonstrates understanding throughout the unit but struggles on the final assessment? This is where our professional judgment matters. A single assessment doesn't always tell the whole story, especially if the format creates barriers that prevent students from demonstrating what they know and can do. We should always consider all the evidence of learning we've collected, including formative assessments, and determine whether we have sufficient evidence that the student has met the intended outcomes. If we're still unsure, we can provide another opportunity for the student to demonstrate their learning using a more accessible format. The goal isn't to replace one score with another. It's to make sure the grade accurately reflects what the student knows and can do. After all, a printing error in my published book doesn't mean I'm not a strong writer, just as a broken oven doesn't mean someone isn't a talented baker.
And remember, summative assessments don't have to be elaborate projects, formal tests, or lengthy written assignments. A student might demonstrate mastery through an informal presentation, an “expert” panel, or another opportunity to apply their learning. What matters is whether we have sufficient, credible evidence that the student has met the intended outcomes.
Ultimately, the purpose of assessment isn't to catch students making mistakes or accumulate enough points to calculate a grade. It's to help students learn, provide us as educators with the information we need to respond to learner variability, and accurately communicate what students know and can do.
